Five Defendants Plead Guilty in Illegal Loansharking, Check Cashing, Gambling & Money Laundering Schemes Linked to Genovese Crime Family

Domenick Pucillo

FLORHAM PARK — Attorney General Gurbir S. Grewal announced that five defendants pleaded guilty in connection with criminal schemes that generated millions of dollars through illegal loan sharking, unlicensed check cashing, gambling, and money laundering. The schemes were linked to the New York-based Genovese organized crime family.

The defendants were indicted in “Operation Fistful,” a joint investigation by the New Jersey Division of Criminal Justice and the Waterfront Commission of New York Harbor, conducted with assistance from the New York and Queens County District Attorneys’ Offices and other law enforcement agencies.

Much of the illicit revenue was collected and laundered through licensed and unlicensed check-cashing businesses in Newark run by alleged Genovese associate Domenick Pucillo. Pucillo and the other associates who were indicted allegedly are part of a New Jersey crew that was operating under the supervision and control of two alleged “made” members of the Genovese crime family –Vito Alberti, a Genovese “soldier” and Charles “Chuckie” Tuzzo, a Genovese “capo” – who answer to the Genovese hierarchy in New York.

The following five defendants pleaded guilty before Superior Court Judge Donald G. Collester Jr. in Morris County:

  1. Domenick Pucillo, 61, of Florham Park, pleaded guilty to first-degree conspiracy to commit money laundering. The state will recommend a sentence of 10 years in prison.
  1. Robert Spagnola, 71, of Morganville, pleaded guilty to second-degree criminal usury. The state will recommend a sentence of five years in prison.
  1. Vito Alberti, 60, of Morristown, pleaded guilty to second-degree criminal usury. The state will recommend a sentence of five years in prison.
  1. Manuel Rodriguez, 53, of Chatham, pleaded guilty to second-degree conspiracy to commit money laundering. The state will recommend a sentence of four years in prison.
  1. Vincent Coppola, 42, of Union City, pleaded guilty to third-degree promoting gambling. The state will recommend a sentence of 180 days in jail and a term of probation.

Assistant Attorney General Annmarie Taggart and Deputy Attorney General Mohammad Mahmood took the guilty pleas for the Division of Criminal Justice Gangs & Organized Crime Bureau. The defendants are scheduled to be sentenced on September 20, 2019.

“When those involved in traditional organized crime engage in schemes such as loansharking and illegal gambling, they profit at the expense of victims who are struggling with debt, gambling problems, and other issues,” said Attorney General Grewal. “By prosecuting the men who ran these schemes and putting key defendants behind bars, we send a message that we will not tolerate these corrosive criminal activities that harm individuals, families and society as a whole.”

“I commend all of the attorneys, detectives and investigators who handled this complex financial investigation and secured these guilty pleas,” said Director Veronica Allende of the Division of Criminal Justice. “These defendants employed elaborate strategies to hide their profits and crimes, but we exposed their schemes through our investigation, in partnership with the Waterfront Commission.”

“This case presents yet another instance of the Waterfront Commission’s concerted efforts with its law enforcement partners to disrupt the influence of organized crime in the metropolitan area,” said New Jersey Commissioner Michael Murphy of the Waterfront Commission of New York Harbor. “The Genovese Crime Family has historically exerted its influence on the Port of New Jersey. Disruption of its profits from gambling, loansharking and money laundering weaken that family’s grip.”

The defendants were charged, in varying combinations, with running the following criminal schemes, which allegedly generated “tribute” payments up the Genovese chain of command:

  • a massive loansharking operation that yielded about $4.7 million in illegal interest (Pucillo, Spagnola, Alberti, Tuzzo [charges pending against Tuzzo]);
  • an illicit multi-million dollar offshore sports gambling enterprise (Coppola, Jerry Albanese [charges pending against Albanese]);
  • an unlicensed check-cashing business that made $9 million in fees in four years, while enabling customers to launder funds and evade taxes by skirting federal reporting requirements (Pucillo, Abel J. Rodrigues [charges pending against Rodrigues], Rodriguez);
  • tax fraud and evasion (Alberti, Spagnola, Coppola, Rodrigues and Rodriguez).

Bureau Chief Lauren Scarpa Yfantis, Assistant Attorney General Annmarie Taggart, former Deputy Attorney General Vincent Militello and Deputy Attorney General Jamie Picard presented the case to the state grand jury for the Division of Criminal Justice Gangs & Organized Crime Bureau. The detectives who conducted Operation Fistful for the Division of Criminal Justice are Lt. Brian Bruton, Sgt. Mario Estrada, Sgt. Patrick Sole and former Detective Matthew Tully, under the supervision of Deputy Chief of Detectives Christopher Donohue and Chief of Detectives Paul Morris.

Attorney General Grewal thanked the Waterfront Commission of New York Harbor for partnering with the Attorney General’s Office in the investigation. The following individuals conducted the investigation for the Waterfront Commission: Capt. Margaret Baldinger, Sgt. George Falvo, Sgt. Kristen Brylinski, Sgt. Michelle Turner, Detective Joseph Longo, Detective Salvatore Arrigo, Detective Andrew Varga, Detective Matthew Moroney, Detective Frank Albanese, Detective Vincent King, and Detective Fauna Mitchell-Foster.

Attorney General Grewal recognized the New York County District Attorney’s Office, in particular Assistant District Attorney Brian Foley, and the Queens County District Attorney’s Office, in particular Executive Assistant District Attorney Peter Crusco, for their work on the investigation. He also recognized Nicole M. Hines, Auditor, and Debra Lewaine, former Supervising Auditor, of the New Jersey Division of Taxation, Office of Criminal Investigation.